FDI (Foreign Direct Investment) in retail sector has been the buzzword in all galleries of society for good and bad reasons. Million of hours of channel time have been spent on it discussing its positives and negatives and still its not stale. This issue is so controversial (at least made so) that it has potential of burning more million hours of discussions on channels. Print media is also not far behind dedicating one full page everyday on this topic and presenting several angles of it. Must say, print media has been more balanced in surgery while channels have been rhetoric. Print media has been neutral and analytic while news channels were mostly engaged in cock-fighting. Its strange to see that supporters of FDI don't find any draw back of it, and opponents any benefits. Support and opposing are divided on party lines while only one guy, Arun Shaurie, crossed it in favor of support. I see, his change of party line was more of a obligatory note to congress for its favor of not screwing much on 2G scam. He was called for discussion and let-go without much grill, which makes sense for returning a favor back and he did it. Period.
Anyways, My blog is not about analyzing support and opposition of FDI, but to put another angle to it. I am currently in opposition to FDI in retail for several reasons. I would put mine at end of the blog but next paragraph is about trying to sketch a disturbing angle to it, which is, desperation of MNCs to jump to it, so desperate that they created pressure on central government through TIME's under-achiever comment, lowering credit rating of India by S&P and several other attempts.
I could understand desperation of Indian government to bring dollars to boost up business, create jobs (take some jobs as well) and reduce inflation, but I don't understand desperation of MNCs to invest in retail sector. My simple theory is this, if one has dollars in its valet, it could go around the world shopping, if one has rupees, perhaps very few places on earth to shop. There are very few things in world which are universally accepted as exchange media, precious metals (gold, silver), some currencies (dollars, EURO, Pounds, Dinar) and raw goods. One can buy anything across world, if it has one of above, sadly, Indian rupee is not in the list. So now, if a USA-based MNC comes to India, spends dollars and starts business, all it would get as profit is Rupees not dollars. What is it going to do with that rupee as its not useful for them back in their country or anywhere else in the world. One way is to ask government to convert these rupees to dollars for them so that they could send it back which would be a little difficult for government sometimes as its always short of elite currencies. If at all, it does so, it would negating the efforts made by intellect-based Indian business which is helpful in bringing dollars to India. Anyways, Govt would not choose to do it, as ultimately it would have rupees in hands which are of course no use for it in international market. Now, why MNCs are so desperate to enter Indian market when Indian currency is not useful for then. Next para tries to sketch the real game.
As I mentioned earlier, raw goods are something acceptable across countries, MNCs would try to purchase raw goods from Indian markets at a cheaper price and sell those in their local markets which would give them the real money, the dollars. This process is logical and should not make harm to anyone if followed religiously. But, this process is complicated, has to follow too many steps before getting actual profit ($$$). Open a store, create a supply chain, sell the goods, get the rupees as profit, purchase new goods with that profit, transport them back to their local stores and then finally get the profit. They would have to invest a fortune in creating supply chain, building storage warehouse, employing people to sell etc before they could start making profit and then real profit ($$$). They could easily cut down a few steps and still get the real-profit ($$$). The long term plan for MNCs would be to purchase goods from farmers, store it in local warehouses and ship it directly to their local market, cutting down steps of opening store, selling goods, making profits, purchasing new goods with profit. Yeah, its a big danger of MNCs creating a siphoning chain from Indian local market to their own local market without touching Indian customers and it would mean, customer wont get that advantage of having cheap goods shopping with these MNCs. They may choose another tricky way of 1%-99% rule. 1% of goods purchased from Indian market available for Indian customers, and 99% directly moving to their local markets without touching Indian customers in the background. There would be some checks placed by law, but Indian state of policies and corruption, it would be cake-walk for MNCs to achieve siphoning without much fuss to be honest. This is a big danger to Indian assets, its cultivation and farmers.
The worry doesn't end here, the 1%-99% rule would create artificial shortage of goods in Indian market as well, which would ultimately lead to high price paid by customers and thus mar the so-called USP of FDI in retail, cheap prices for consumers. The immense purchasing power of MNCs and solid robust, modern tools for storage would mean mass-scale purchase from Indian farmers (u sell cheap when u sell in bulk), modern technology would not let the good destroy and it would reach EUROPE, USA markets before we could know of it.
Some MNCs may choose to go the patriotic way, investing and growing in India itself with the profit itself, but its not that patriotic at all. Investing in Indian ventures with that profit would mean increasing ownership of foreign companies in Indian industries, land and institutions and would create a parallel power-center with the Indian government itself. Retail is a sector which touches every single Indian on soil as its related to their daily needs, means huge market, huge opportunities to exploit laws of the land and create turbulence in long term.
Hope, this angle was not covered anywhere on media, but if or if not, let me know through your comments.
Anyways, My blog is not about analyzing support and opposition of FDI, but to put another angle to it. I am currently in opposition to FDI in retail for several reasons. I would put mine at end of the blog but next paragraph is about trying to sketch a disturbing angle to it, which is, desperation of MNCs to jump to it, so desperate that they created pressure on central government through TIME's under-achiever comment, lowering credit rating of India by S&P and several other attempts.
I could understand desperation of Indian government to bring dollars to boost up business, create jobs (take some jobs as well) and reduce inflation, but I don't understand desperation of MNCs to invest in retail sector. My simple theory is this, if one has dollars in its valet, it could go around the world shopping, if one has rupees, perhaps very few places on earth to shop. There are very few things in world which are universally accepted as exchange media, precious metals (gold, silver), some currencies (dollars, EURO, Pounds, Dinar) and raw goods. One can buy anything across world, if it has one of above, sadly, Indian rupee is not in the list. So now, if a USA-based MNC comes to India, spends dollars and starts business, all it would get as profit is Rupees not dollars. What is it going to do with that rupee as its not useful for them back in their country or anywhere else in the world. One way is to ask government to convert these rupees to dollars for them so that they could send it back which would be a little difficult for government sometimes as its always short of elite currencies. If at all, it does so, it would negating the efforts made by intellect-based Indian business which is helpful in bringing dollars to India. Anyways, Govt would not choose to do it, as ultimately it would have rupees in hands which are of course no use for it in international market. Now, why MNCs are so desperate to enter Indian market when Indian currency is not useful for then. Next para tries to sketch the real game.
As I mentioned earlier, raw goods are something acceptable across countries, MNCs would try to purchase raw goods from Indian markets at a cheaper price and sell those in their local markets which would give them the real money, the dollars. This process is logical and should not make harm to anyone if followed religiously. But, this process is complicated, has to follow too many steps before getting actual profit ($$$). Open a store, create a supply chain, sell the goods, get the rupees as profit, purchase new goods with that profit, transport them back to their local stores and then finally get the profit. They would have to invest a fortune in creating supply chain, building storage warehouse, employing people to sell etc before they could start making profit and then real profit ($$$). They could easily cut down a few steps and still get the real-profit ($$$). The long term plan for MNCs would be to purchase goods from farmers, store it in local warehouses and ship it directly to their local market, cutting down steps of opening store, selling goods, making profits, purchasing new goods with profit. Yeah, its a big danger of MNCs creating a siphoning chain from Indian local market to their own local market without touching Indian customers and it would mean, customer wont get that advantage of having cheap goods shopping with these MNCs. They may choose another tricky way of 1%-99% rule. 1% of goods purchased from Indian market available for Indian customers, and 99% directly moving to their local markets without touching Indian customers in the background. There would be some checks placed by law, but Indian state of policies and corruption, it would be cake-walk for MNCs to achieve siphoning without much fuss to be honest. This is a big danger to Indian assets, its cultivation and farmers.
The worry doesn't end here, the 1%-99% rule would create artificial shortage of goods in Indian market as well, which would ultimately lead to high price paid by customers and thus mar the so-called USP of FDI in retail, cheap prices for consumers. The immense purchasing power of MNCs and solid robust, modern tools for storage would mean mass-scale purchase from Indian farmers (u sell cheap when u sell in bulk), modern technology would not let the good destroy and it would reach EUROPE, USA markets before we could know of it.
Some MNCs may choose to go the patriotic way, investing and growing in India itself with the profit itself, but its not that patriotic at all. Investing in Indian ventures with that profit would mean increasing ownership of foreign companies in Indian industries, land and institutions and would create a parallel power-center with the Indian government itself. Retail is a sector which touches every single Indian on soil as its related to their daily needs, means huge market, huge opportunities to exploit laws of the land and create turbulence in long term.
Hope, this angle was not covered anywhere on media, but if or if not, let me know through your comments.